THE BATTLE OF THE MISSION TAQUERIAS

 

THE CONTENDERS:

Baja California (Van Ness & 16th St)
El Buen Sabor (Valencia & 18th St)
El Farolito (Mission & 24th St)
El Metate (Bryant & 22nd St)
El Tonayense (24th & Shotwell)
La Corneta (Mission & 23rd St)
Taqueria Cancun (Mission & 18th St)
Taqueria San Jose (Mission & 24th St)

       
In an effort to name the best neighborhood taqueria, we gathered menus from 13 places. After eliminating five of the more expensive places, we selected five of what were considered the most popular, yet traditional, items from each of the remaining eight taquerias - carne asada burritos, tacos al pastor, quesadillas suiza with chicken, ceviche and various veggie items - and held a blind taste-off for 15 of our most discriminating friends.  

After stuffing ourselves silly in the name of research, we turned in our ballots. So, whose cuisine reigns supreme (OK, we stole that from "Iron Chef")?

NOTE: These findings are based solely on the quality of the food; ambiance and cleanliness of the taquerias were not factors in the voting, since we took all the food to go.

Our unofficial, far-from-scientific findings are as follows:  
 

 

BEST CARNE ASADA BURRITO:
Taqueria Cancun's version, with its grilled, slightly crunchy tortilla and fresh avocado, was the favorite, followed by El Tonayense and La Corneta,

BEST TACOS AL PASTOR:
El Farolito's were pleasingly spicy and not too greasy; Cancun and El Buen Sabor also ranked high.

BEST CHICKEN QUESADILLA SUIZA:
It's Farolito again, with their juicy, white-meat chicken and homemade tortillas, tying El Buen Sabor's savory offering for first place, with Taqueria San Jose and El Tonayense in second and third place.

BEST CEVICHE:
La Corneta won this round, with Cancun's spicy version coming in second place. Farolito's might have fared better if they'd packed the tostada separately; it was soggy by the time we all dug in.

 

BEST CHILE RELLENO:
Baja California, with the perfect level of cheese and spice, took this one, with San Jose and El Tonayense rounding out the top three.
*Subcategory: Tonayense was short one of the chiles for our order, so they threw in a veggie tamale, which was moist and delicious.

BEST VEGGIE BURRITO:
Cancun was the favorite, followed by El Tonayense and Farolito. Many tasters said El Metate's version with seasonal vegetables tasted more Asian than Mexican.
*Subcategory: We tried chile relleno burritos from El Buen Sabor and La Corneta, with the latter edging out Buen Sabor's version, which had too much rice and not enough chile.

OTHER NOTES:
Farolito scored merit points for its amazing green salsa and for being the cheapest, Tonayense's chips were a favorite, and San Jose had delicious red salsa, but lost points for being the most expensive place included the tasting.


Photos by Christopher Lautz